Discover Bethany, NY: A Blend of Nature and Mystery
Skip to Main Content

Discover Bethany, NY: A Blend of Nature and Mystery

by Lauren Humphrey

Nestled in the tranquil town of Bethany, New York, where history and nature harmoniously coexist, the oldest county forest in the state beckons explorers and outdoor enthusiasts. Founded in 1812, Bethany boasts a rich history and a strong connection to the great outdoors, making it the perfect destination for those seeking a peaceful escape.

A Glimpse into Bethany's Past

Bethany's history dates back to its settlement in 1803. Officially established in 1812, this rural community boasts a past shrouded in mystery and intrigue. Alongside the town's peaceful landscapes and rolling hills, Bethany holds a unique distinction as the home of the enigmatic Rolling Hills Asylum and the infamous unsolved "Linden Murders" that transpired during the 1920s. The mysterious cases of "Ruth," Frances Kimball, and the triple homicides of Tom Whaley, Hattie Whaley, and Mabel Morse continue to intrigue and baffle those who delve into the dark tales of Western New York. For more information on the Linden Murders, take a short trip to Batavia to visit the Holland Land Office Museum.

Unsolved Linden Murders Exhibit at Holland Land Office Museum

The crown jewel of Bethany, without a doubt, is the Genesee County Park & Interpretive Center. Spread across 431 acres of pristine land, this park showcases the raw beauty of the oldest county forest in New York State. Visitors can immerse themselves in the great outdoors, thanks to an array of well-maintained trails that meander through rolling hills and lush woodlands.

What sets this park apart is its commitment to education and appreciation of the natural world. The Interpretive Center hosts a variety of year-round programs and activities, providing an opportunity to connect with nature in meaningful ways. From mesmerizing Owl prowls and captivating monarch butterfly watches to serene birding walks and rejuvenating yoga sessions, there's something for everyone.

For those seeking outdoor recreation, the park offers an abundance of options. Explore the self-guided nature trails, bring out your inner child on the playgrounds and ball fields, or experience the exhilaration of tobogganing down the snowy hills in winter. If you prefer a leisurely picnic amidst nature's grandeur, you'll find pavilions available for rent, including one with a cozy stone fireplace for chilly days.

Throughout the year, the park accommodates visitors with flush toilets and running water from May to October, while port-a-johns and restrooms inside the Interpretive Nature Center are available Thursday to Sunday for the rest of the year. Winter brings added delights, such as snowshoe rentals, cross-country skiing, and sledding, making Genesee County Park a year-round haven for nature enthusiasts.

Pond Discovery at the Genesee County Park & Forest
Interpretive Nature Center at the Genesee County Park & Forest

A Dash of Art and Antiques: Bethany Arts and Antiques

After a day of basking in the natural beauty of Genesee County Park, continue your Bethany adventure with a visit to Bethany Arts and Antiques. This unique shop showcases a curated collection of antique items, each with its own story to tell. As you browse, don't miss the opportunity to admire the owner's original artwork, adding a touch of creativity to your experience.

For those looking for a more hands-on experience, Bethany Arts also offers classes. Whether you're looking to expand your creative horizons or simply want to have a few hours of artistic fun, you'll find a range of class options to choose from. Learn the art of needle felting, experiment with alcohol ink on tiles, or try your hand at painting and silk scarf dying.

A Brush with the Paranormal: Rolling Hills Asylum

For those with a taste for the mysterious, our next stop is Rolling Hills Asylum. Steeped in history and known worldwide as one of the most haunted locations in the country, Rolling Hills Asylum offers an experience like no other.

Originally built in 1827 as the Genesee County Poor Farm, this place has seen its fair share of stories and legends. Later additions, such as the Genesee County Infirmary and the Genesee County Nursing Home, have only added to the mystery surrounding it. From Class A EVPs to encounters with real spirits, paranormal enthusiasts from across the globe flock here. The asylum has even been featured on popular TV shows like "Ghost Adventures" and "Ghost Hunters." Whether you're a skeptic or a believer, a visit to Rolling Hills Asylum will leave you intrigued and perhaps a little spooked.

The asylum offers self-guided public and private ghost hunts, historical tours, special events, and even celebrity appearances.

A Delicious Stop: Jen's Joint

As the day winds down, it’s time to satisfy your hunger at Jen’s Joint, a cozy diner serving up breakfast and lunch. Sit back and savor your favorite comfort foods in a warm and friendly atmosphere.

A Day Filled with Nature, History, and the Unexplained

In Bethany, New York, the allure lies in its serene landscapes, rich history, and commitment to preserving the natural world. The Genesee County Park & Interpretive Center, a sanctuary of nature, invites you to reconnect with the outdoors and find solace in its breathtaking beauty. Come for the history, stay for the beauty, and leave with a deep appreciation for this idyllic corner of Western New York. Bethany awaits, promising a day filled with exploration, relaxation, and unforgettable memories.

Get your FREE Genesee County

Vacation Planner

Stay Connected

Sign up for our FREE email Newsletter