Best Places to Get Ice Cream in Genesee County
Genesee County’s ice cream shops are more than just places to grab a dessert—they’re community hubs that bring people together and create lasting memories.
Whether you’re a local resident or just passing through, supporting these local businesses enriches the community and ensures these sweet traditions continue for generations.
Ready to start your ice cream adventure? Share your favorite spots and flavors with us, and don’t forget to visit the featured ice cream shops to savor the best of Genesee County.
Batavia, NY
Blondie's is a locals' favorite way to end a walk around the DeWitt Recreation Area. The ice cream parlor offers your favorite frozen treats and features a drive-thru and walk-up window. Located on the Ellicott Trail and next to DeWitt Recreation Area, enjoy the flavor of the week's ice cream cone as you walk the trail along DeWitt Lake.
Dave's is the first shop to open each season. Throughout the season, Dave features different flavors of soft-serve ice cream. A drive-thru walk-up window and indoor seating are also available. Look for their unique soft-serve twist flavors that change frequently.
Lickity Splits is open during the summer, serving Perry’s Ice Cream in your favorite cone. Grab a treat at the walk-up window, or stay inside your vehicle and take advantage of the drive-thru.
Oliver's is open year-round and serves hard ice cream and specialty sundaes, with custard added in the warmer months. You can enjoy your ice cream outside at the picnic tables or walk around the chocolate shop.
Settler's is your go-to spot if you haven’t tried a warm, bubbly waffle cone with your ice cream. Serving more than just a sweet treat, Settler’s offers American and Mediterranean comfort food. You’ll be pleasantly surprised at their choices of Mac and Cheese.
Bergen, NY
The Bergen Country deli offers more than deli delights; the Hershey’s ice cream selection is worth the trip. What makes ice cream even better? Grabbing a donut from Dunkin Donuts inside.
Elba, NY
Sweet Life Country Store is a delightful spot that combines shopping and ice cream. It's a unique experience that you won't want to miss. You'll enjoy Oliver's candies, coffee, honey, maple syrup, and local handmade items.
LeRoy, NY
LeRoy's No Finer Diner is a beloved local eatery serving fantastic ice cream. It's a great place to enjoy a meal and dessert. Choose from unique flavors like Birthday Batter, Cappuccino Crunch, Salty Caramel Crunch, and more.
Alabama, NY
Straight Out the Boot in Alabama is a unique spot that offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a cajun flair. Their ice cream is a must-try.
Corfu, NY
Corfu's Sprinkles Creamery is an ice cream shop that serves Perry's ice cream and custard in a warm, welcoming atmosphere. If you are a coffee lover, try the Mocha Caramel Coffee Float. It doesn't disappoint. Choose from the drive-thru or the walk-up window to order your next sweet treat.
